Animated Achievements

DC might have a firm grip on animated superheroes thanks to its parent company owning a A-list animation studio, but Marvel are beginning to become contenders thanks in small part to Disney and the popularity of its live-action movies. On Tuesday, Sony <a href="http://www.newsarama.com/27288-sony-delays-animated-spider-man-movie.html">scheduled the first animated Spider-Man feature film for December 21, 2018</A>, with A-list writers Phil Lord and Chris Miller plotting out that story. That'll be the second animated adaptation of a Marvel character after the the Oscar-winning <I>Big Hero 6</I>. <p>With more new animated features in the works from Marvel, DC, as well as elsewhere, we're once again taking a look at some of the very best comic book-based animated features. So, not TV series (we <a href=http://www.newsarama.com/tv/10-best-comic-book-animated-series-ever-111018.html>did that one already</a>), but feature-length productions; which have become more numerous in recent years. <p>Note: For the purpose of this list, we're counting animated features based on American comic books — the considerable history of manga and anime deserves its own list. <p><I>Lucas Siegel and Albert Ching contributed to earlier versions of this article</I>.

Batman Beyond: Return Of The Joker

Bruce Timm and Paul Dini's DC universe did more than just exist in the "present day," it also went about 40 years into the future, where Bruce Wayne had retired and a new kid, Terry McGinnis had taken up the mantle under Wayne's tutelage. The TV series <b>Batman Beyond</b> was a fan favorite, but the high point was the feature length film that showed how the Joker returned despite dying at the hands of well, we won't tell you here. <p>This movie had Tim Drake, Nightwing, Harley Quinn, Barbara Gordon.It had crazy plot twists, amazing action, scenes set in the past and future. it had Mark Hamill and Arleen Sorkin as just the start of a voice cast that reads as a who's who. And of course, the plot to the movie itself is just incredible. It's a testament not just to how cool Batman is, but how enduring his greatest foe is, as well. <p>The popularity of this movie, and <I>Batman Beyond</I> as a whole, led to this concept being revived recently back in DC Comics -- with a new man under the Bat-cowl.

Justice League: Doom

When the long-planned Justice League live-action movie comes to fruition, it'll have a tough time living up to <b>Justice League: Doom</b> in terms of the amount of heroes, villains and action this 2012 animated feature was able to deliver. <p>Reuniting much of the <i>Justice League</i> animated series cast along with the returns of Tim Daly as Superman and Nathan Fillion as Hal Jordan, <b>Justice League: Doom</b> was a loose adaptation of the acclaimed Mark Waid-written "Tower of Babel" story arc in <i>JLA</i>. Not only did the movie include Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman, Flash, Green Lantern, Martian Manhunter and Cyborg, it also incorporated an A-list Legion of Doom consisting of Vandal Savage, Metallo, Bane, Cheetah, Star Sapphire and Mirror Master. <p><b>Justice League Doom</b> was written by late animation and comic book veteran Dwayne McDuffie and released posthumously. Despite fitting all that action and all those characters into just a 77-minute running time, it kept the exploration of Batman's role in the Justice League that made the original "Tower of Babel" an intriguing tale.

Planet Hulk

While Marvel and Universal fight over a live-action <I>Hulk</I> movie, Marvel already adapted the storyline on the lips of everyone wanting a another feature film with <I>Planet Hulk</I>. Although the setting and characters might tax even Marvel Studios' pocketbook in live-action, Greg Pak and Carlo Pagulayan's story thrives in animation thanks to the work of Madhouse. <p>As one of Japan's most thriving anime houses, Madhouse brought an energy rarely seen in American-centric storytelling to <I>Planet Hulk</I> -- and Hulk benefited from that, both in the visual style as well as the pacing. <p>With frequent Marvel voice actor Rick D. Wasserman in the title role, Madhouse and Marvel Animation managed to cohesively introduce a plethora of new characters while still making it a Hulk-centric story. <p>Both the comic book and animated film versions of <I>Planet Hulk</I> stand on their own, but should Marvel Studios ever get serious about a new live-action Hulk film then they've already got a game plan sitting on shelves.

Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 1 and 2

Although released in two feature-length parts, Warner Bros. Animation's <I>The Dark Knight Returns</I> should be viewed as one larger movie. Comic book fans are used to serialization, so why not do that for animation? <p>Based of course off the famous comic book of the same name by Frank Miller, <I>The Dark Knight Returns</I> is held back a little by the studio's decision to split into two movies, with part 1 being heavy on set-up while part 2 being wall-to-wall action. But if you have a couple hours uninterrupted, the preference is watching it all in one sitting. <p>We should warn you, the final battle with the Joker is tough to watch. It is brutal and violent and raw and it feels more like you're really watching the Batman break down because of it. The fight with Superman is similarly brutal, but gives the viewer a stronger sense of triumph though the final twist that fans who haven't read the series should stop a few hearts from beating -- at least for a little bit. <p>It's impressive just to see this series made into film at all, but to do it oh-so-right means so much more.

All-Star Superman

There have been great animated movies based on original screenplays, but if you do base it off specific source material, it never hurts to have something as great as Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely's <I>All-Star Superman</I>. Dwayne McDuffie expertly took the original 12 issue series and pulled it into a cohesive feature-length screenplay. <p>The surprise voice casting of James Denton in the title role might have been a little bit jarring for long-time DC animated fans, but the former <I>Desperate Housewives</I> star really excelled beyond just what's on his IMDb resume here. <p>For fans who weren't too pleased with <I>Man of Steel</I> as a modern definitive Superman movie, this 2011 gem has exactly what you need.

Batman: Under The Red Hood

In one of the quickest turnarounds from comic books to animation, 2010's <b>Batman: Under the Red Hood</b> took its cues from the 2005-2006 Judd Winick-written "Under the Hood" story which detailed former Robin Jason Todd's return to life as a dangerous antihero, following his newsworthy demise at the hands of the Joker in "A Death in the Family." <p>That's some heavy (and complicated) material to handle in a single animated feature, and it helped that Winick himself wrote the screenplay (a pattern that continued in 2012's <i>Superman vs. The Elite</i>, written by Joe Kelly). <p>The work of renowned casting/vocal director Andrea Romano yielded some unconventional yet effective choices for <b>Under the Red Hood</b>, including Bruce Greenwood as Batman, Neil Patrick Harris as Nightwing, <i>Supernatural</i>'s Jensen Ackles as Jason Todd, and John "Bender" DiMaggio as the Joker.

Justice League: The New Frontier

The film adaptation of Darwyn Cooke's six-issue epic bringing the DC heroes back into the Golden Age is something special. Not only was this the second in Warner's DC Universe Animated Original Movies, but it bucked all expectations by keeping the 1950s setting, and managing to successfully animate Cooke's artwork in a way that made it seem to jump off the page. <p>The 75 minute limit to Warner's DC movies reared its ugly head here, cutting some of the subplots out and leaving many fans wishing it could have been split in two. The story is a familiar one — the heroes of DC Comics come together to defeat an alien threat — but the process of getting there is unique. <p><b>New Frontier</b> is also notable for one of the best Wonder Woman scenes ever put to screen, with Lucy Lawless voicing the original Warrior princess.

Big Hero 6

The newest addition to our line-up in this outing, <I>Big Hero 6</I> is a animated powerhouse that used it's relative obscurity in comic books to its advantage in seguing to the big screen. <p>Like a Cinderella story in real life, Walt Disney Animation plucked the <I>Big Hero 6</I> concept from Marvel's back issue bin after they were acquired, and took the comic books as a first draft and elaborated, expanded and added a heaping helping of charm to make this 20 year-old concept feel as fresh as an apple plucked right from the tree. <p>With technical prowess out the wazoo in terms of animation (especially in regards to the microbots), Walt Disney Animation Studios turned this from a Marvel after-thought into a story you were (and still are) surprised Marvel hasn't taken advantage of back in the source comic books. <p>While for Disney fans it still falls into the immense shadow of <I>Frozen</I>, <i>Big Hero 6</I> is the little engine that could -- even if comic book fans aren't that quick to accept it as one of their own.

Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox

Some might say our list is a bit Justice League heavy -- but that probably just means you haven't seen this film. <p>Based on 2011's <I>Flashpoint</I> comic book crossover, this animated movie is arguably better than it's source material -- thanks to the need to be standalone. The 81 minute time limit forced screenwriter James Krieg and director Jay Oliva to streamline the story to focus on Flash's core story, and even going so far as beefing that up even with the expanded part of Professor Zoom. <p>And you can't talk about this movie without talking about <I>that</I> death scene, which is even more graphic than Geoff Johns and Andy Kubert's original comic book. For some it's still a bone of contention (especially considering it was rated PG-13), but for others including us seeing it as the punctuation the original comic book sorely missed. <p>Warner Bros. relies on its talented bench of DC voice actors, while bringing in some a-list additions like Kevin McKidd as Thomas Wayne and C. Thomas Howell as Eobard Thawne. If you liked David Tennant's creepy Kilgrave in <I>Jessica Jones</I>, wait until you get a load of Zoom.

Batman: Mask of the Phantasm

Sandwiched between live-action films <i>Batman Returns</i> and <i>Batman Forever</i>, 1993's <b>Batman: Mask of the Phantasm</b> was an extension of the celebrated <i>Batman: The Animated Series</i>, and offered a take on the Dark Knight very different from Tim Burton's or Joel Schumacher's. <p><b>Mask of the Phantasm</b> was a 76-minute testament to the stylish storytelling power of <i>B:TAS</i>, encapsulating much of what was so great about that show in a slightly different form. Though there was Batman and the Joker, it introduced a wholly new element to the mythos in the form of Andrew Beaumont/The Phantasm, who later appeared in animated series tie-in comics and <i>Justice League Unlimited</i>. <p>The fact that <b>Batman: Mask of the Phantasm</b> was the first film on the list to be released theatrically doesn't give it prestige by itself, but it is certainly notable, and a testament to the quality and appeal of this take on Batman, even if its box office impact was small. <p><b>Mask of the Phantasm</b> helped inspire just about all of the films on this list, and especially subsequent Batman animated features like <i>SubZero</i>. <p>23 years later, while animation innovations have outpaced <I>Batman: Mask of the Phantasm</I>, it can't take away the potency and craftsmanship of the original.

10 BEST Comic Book-Based Animated Features of All Time

Date: 22 December 2015 Time: 12:00 AM ET